w.r.t. “Loud in War”

comments by Robert P. Maccubin, Charles Tomlinson, Derek Mahon, the editors of The Yale Journal of Criticism

Love it—start to finish. I tried to read it in one breath but had to pause once—I think it was in a passage where there wasn’t anything politically incorrect.”—Robert P. Maccubin

It has the quality of intelligent conversation raised to a pitch of accuracy.”—Charles Tomlinson

Formidable.”—Derek Mahon

A fascinating, provocative and playful piece.”—The editors of the Yale Journal of Criticism